David Yates really wanted to make a black-and-white film

Review of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (2009) by salvius23: 👎 3.5/5

Weirdly desaturated and weirdly disjointed. Slughorn's description of the magic fish gift from Lily Potter might be the best scene in the entire series, and most of the credit for that goes to Jim Broadbent. A better writer would probably have introduced the "horcrux" concept earlier in the series, instead of awkwardly shoehorning it in, as if suddenly realizing that Dumbledore needed to deliver some of this exposition, and there wasn't much time left for him to do that.