no thank you
Review of Kill Bill: The Whole Bloody Affair (2006) by screenqueeen: π 2.5/5
i'm realizing how different i've become since seeing this and remembering how much both volumes rocked my world at 13 and 14 years old. but this as one whole film just doesn't work. it brings everything to the forefront, all the little gags and references which, now that i have explored martial arts, crime and some tokusatsu flicks, i keep seeing what tarantino is doing "cleverly" and it has turned around towards the obnoxious.
the first half feels tighter, faster even and in effect altogether better. it in turn makes even more clear that there's some real moments of true inspiration that is captured perfectly with a resounding loving "yes, and" that becomes part of the conversation around modern martial arts films. volume 1's big set piece remains a highlight and is the most fun thing i've ever experienced in a tarantino movie but that's probably because it knows it has a purpose and doesn't get slowed down by a sense of self pride, in the same way a lot of characters engage in cultural appropriation so much that Tarantino's attitude towards it is telling.
but everything else seems to expect to be as great as the things that have come before. revenge martial arts and action films are the medium's bread and butter but there's something else on this film's mind as evidenced in volume 2's rambling contemplations. nothing offered there provides depth to the actions of the first half. it doesn't need to but that's what it seems like it's doing and as a result just feels like someone who has brought something really fun and interesting to a conversation has nothing else insightful to say, lingering after the moment has ended and the party winds down, ending up leaving awkwardly once they're the last person to leave while the host just wants to clean and get some rest.
the second half has its moments but it's largely unearned & hollow in the face of using homage and ripping off in good faith to bridge the gap between halves. i've historically enjoyed tarantino dialogue but it's particularly not great here because revenge action never put its stakes in spoken plot or story beats. in fact revenge cinema finds strength in creating and challenging stakes by creating them with the language of shot composition, editing, iconography, unspoken beats of actors faces communicating something understood without the need to deliver a 10 minute monologue about superman.
in those 10 minutes i learned a little more now about how tarantino sees his Bill character. yes, he's evil. yes, he's gross. yes, he is manipulative and uses the dirtiest tricks in the book to get what he wants. but the film continually gives him respect that only a toxic person like tarantino could pay without having to say "the guy's a piece of shit but I gotta hand it to him -- he's one cool son of a bitch." i could tell he's modeled after weinstein and the way that tarantino just models him with all the worst things about him translated into a genre film cipher but with an aftertaste of cool guy makes me think that this is a director who can get himself into trouble every time he opens his mouth yet knows somehow that protecting sexual abusers is best done when you shut the fuck up about it and contribute no opinions or evidence publicly or privately.
there is a whole lot more that went on in my mind seeing this in the theater but the only other thing I'll mention is how this is decidedly a story of woman's revenge but it cheaply centers on pregnancy and abduction, essentially introduced as a catalyst but then yanked from Thurman's character throughout almost all of this until the final couple sequences. her child being taken from her in both senses never feels like the motive even in her blood soaked rage of the first half. none of the conversations ever dip into that territory, despite how close it gets in the opening scene between her and Fox's Copperhead coming to blows in her suburban home with her own daughter hiding in her room. it feels like a traumatic situation invented in lieu of personality that tarantino never thought to include in Thurman's character, and you don't get a real sense of it outside of her conversation with Bill outside the chapel during the wedding rehearsal. if tarantino wants to build on characters during these dialogue heavy scenes, i feel that you should at least grant her a personal agency of who she is and who she wants to be.
it's a sad realization but i'm glad i came to it on my own: KILL BILL is a fun drug but the comedown is devastating and depressing.