estrogen could save her, if --

Review of Surrender Dorothy (1998) by screenqueeen: 👎 1/5

something about this tugged at me the wrong way and continued as the credits rolled (rolled? i can't remember if there was a scroll or if this was low budget enough to warrant static cards at the end). obviously the subject matter got away from writer/director/editor/actor Kevin DiNovis and this no longer serves purely as an examination of domestic violence the way DiNovis originally intended. he deliberately superimposed a man onto the traditional women's role of being the receiving end of this kind of abuse to highlight the despicable and unacceptable nature of this ever happening to another human being, regardless of gender. the trans forcefemming aspect of this is a late addition in the script and the treatment of this aspect of the film is the entire reason i could not get on board with any of it.

it is very apparent that Trevor is a misogynist in every capitulation and this story is very much rooted in his perspective. we follow him everywhere and learn about his habits, his routines, his dark side. the poorly realized character of Lanh Boy (in more ways than one, more so the intention of him being played by a Vietnamese actor \[???????]) becomes a target of abuse purely out of convenience for Trevor, up to and including the assignment of menial & typically degrading work that is unquestionably gendered negatively. the thing is the point is consistently made every other scene how Trevor is going to abuse Lahn this time, slowly escalating and then rapidly jumping to a point of no return for everything in this film.

it's the lack of any other kind of voice or argument despite the director playing the fucking character who could provide some counterpoint to the highlight of abuse experienced underneath the influence of Trevor. the focus that DiNovis says he intends to work within loses credibility first and foremost when he says he wants to shed light on heteronormative domestic and sexual abuse. but this falls apart when that abuse manifests in primarily the forced servitude in "wifely duties," actual physical abuse and sexual objectification and never focuses on the one experiencing the abuse. we have all seen too many films, read too many books, perhaps even been in too many real relationships where the voice of the abused is never heard. maybe that is the point here, if so it does nothing different than any other domestic drama or horror film with these elements other than its tacked-on trans imagery. this is something to be expected from a small creative team working on a cis man's penned script, revised who knows how many times around the core concept of the fact that he knows how to get people to pay attention to the horrors of domestic abuse.

the attitude DiNovis introduces as the argumentative reasoning for the film's trans themes don't feel much better than Trevor's written intentions. it's a means of control and tethering, projecting an image onto someone who does not identify this way (literally rendered in the film's opening credit sequence). but the bleak nature of there being no hope for something that feels so damning and irreversible by the time Lanh discovers what Trevor has been doing, the universal response is that of disgust and imprisonment. i'm not suggesting that Lanh become suddenly appreciative of being freed from the shackles of manhood for any of this film's argument to hold water. i'm laying into how there isn't really an argument here.

we are shown so many different situations and depictions of abuse between the same two people that we feel there is no way out. even by the film's closing moments nothing comes of any issue DiNovis is trying to raise other than what is wrong with it. surely he had some idea of what to convey other than simply the horrors of how he would imagine being on the receiving end of it?

this feels like the most half-baked art film shrug that tries to shoot for a good cause but slips hard, into territory that someone like John Waters could tell anyone that putting this as a straight drama ignores key aspects of humanity even in the hateful cycles of abuse so prominent in every moment of this.