s'ok
Review of SLC Punk (1998) by screenqueeen: 👍 3/5
a fun movie that starts to think that its some great hidden american novel framed within Stevo, its unreliable narrator. however this rings pretty hollow in the wake of TRAINSPOTTING, a punk film in a different way that never tries to call attention to itself as punk yet is that in how it carries itself in a collectivist manner. SLC PUNK is decidedly individualist but is convinced it's collectivist.
one thing that gets pointed out very specifically is the dichotomy of those who align with punk for the ideologies backed by political theories critical to the movement, the music and clothing, etc. coming secondary in the whole affair. of course the irony of having Stevo be the voice for this issue is revealed to the audience but his ignorance doesn't really become an item of study. his consistent misunderstanding of anarchism leads directly to that which facilitates the notion where he believes he can change a system from the inside. grandstanding on the platform that you're not a "real punk" if you're only aligning yourself with the fashion falls flat when that argument rests on the fact that you're only punk because your friend got you into it.
in a flashback scene where his parents talk to him about his rebellion (where he sports an olympian-sized mohawk) Stevo calls them both out on their still-held beliefs versus what they have devoted their lives and resources to recently that directly contradicts those values they hold so dear. no one is there to deliver this to Stevo. the film loses depth due to this, granting the core friendship of Bob and Stevo an infallibility that just never becomes challenged in any real sense. any of the women in this could have provided those challenges for them but both the characters and the film (by extension the filmmaker Merendino, too) remove them from any critical position before their relationships can grow to become crucial to how either Bob or Stevo see their selves within this version of punk culture. an adage that is apparently known to the male punks confirms a deeply rooted sexism, uttered almost religiously in the film's third act: "only posers fall in love with girls." when he meets Brandy, a woman is finally given agency to question the foundation of Stevo's beliefs but is whisked away as quickly as she is introduced. despite how important she is according to Stevo's fourth wall breaking narration, the framed actions of excluding her speaks otherwise.
there's an unspoken issue of having Stevo be the defining voice of punk in this whole film: he doesn't see himself as one but he is bigoted. and you can't be a punk and also be one of those. it's on the fucking sign! every character other than Stevo in the scene is punk. especially Trish and Mike. be more like Trish and Mike.