go fuck yourself

Review of The Black Phone (2022) by screenqueeen: 👎 1/5

17/100

Joe Hill and i have never really clicked. i've fallen hard out of love with King too and don't think i'm ever really going to willfully dive into any more of his books or adaptations. Hill has been in the position to show that he's not his father but by really seeming like he's not he comes off as a ripoff imitation artist instead. what happens here is just that but it leans more into bigoted tropes while convincing itself it's above any kind of thinking or treatment like that. at a certain point when the adaptation of his vampire vanity license plate tv show was getting a lot of talk and praise i dipped my head under the surface but found nothing to grab onto there. i think it would be easy to say that i'm just allergic to whatever he does but i don't know. that seems like sidestepping the real reasons why this sucks in particular. i'm thinking that my dislike of this film is a pretty reasonable response to an endorsement of xenophobic and misogynist patterns in King's writing, that which Hill has adopted with an all-or-nothing approach as if this were the formula to coca-cola and changing a single thing would be a grievous sin\* to the pantheon of the gods of horror literature.

the film invents its own patterns of Kingian society: a vaguely abusive father who never does anything on screen yet his quiet fury implies violent intent (played bizarrely by Jeremy Davies as if this were some offshoot of a character from Justified); a boy of Mexican descent whom no one stands up for yet takes on the role of protecting the white main character at his own expense; the motivation for the grabber to be completely removed from any sexual context in the script yet Derrickson visually sexualizes him anyway -- specifically in the punishments he devises -- without ever examining this rift or acknowledging that there is one. this specific avoidance reads as cowardly and homophobic to me, in that it's uncomfortable in depicting a bad guy like Al as gay (whether or not that's particularly tied to his victims) but it's ok to vaguely point to that in showing him sitting at the top of the stairs shirtless wielding a belt to gleefully punish a child trying to escape. what's more, the original story's version of the grabber is just Hill freely dispensing fatphobia and putting a disgusting human being's actions behind what he considers "grotesque" (pg. 1) and "ungainly fat ... a hippo performing ballet" (pg. 14) as he dehumanizes based on one physical trait, yet the monstrous things Al does and has done pale in comparison to color the disgust surrounding him.

the feeling i get from this is a reverence to a school of nostalgia that excuses appropriation of stereotypes and slurs. depiction is not endorsement but when there is a pattern of specific depictions that get put up on a pedestal (especially in the case of King/Hill), that reads as an open indulgence to me. patterns shift and while King will never write black characters like he did in the 70s ever again, there are plenty of textures within americana to mine & exploit. his son Hill seems to like dipping into exploiting his father's own indulgence of exploitation as a way to depict the past as if he'd rather just be back there now. this movie feels like it operates under the delusion that it's not contributing to any sort of harmful racism or sexism or homophobia but it's doing exactly those things. this is its motivation and its raison d'être but no one will ever admit that.

there were excellent performances here and i did get one bit of decent tension out of it but this is the kind of stuff i think the horror community needs to put behind them and acknowledge.

\*for the record, i am on the side of putting cocaine back into coca-cola