Clowning Myself Part Two

Review of It: Chapter Two (2019) by nezzkobdamned: 👍 7.3/10

This is a tough one to call. Ever since a 13-year-old me first read the book and fell in love with it, I've always wanted and feared an adaptation. The TV miniseries has its moments, but ultimately fell way below my expectations. I enjoyed a lot about 2017's IT, especially as it made the cast gel together in a better way than I'd expected. It was still a little ineffective with its scares though.

Chapter two continues that. The adult cast generally match up well not only to their youthful selves (some amazing casting), but the source material, even with the changes. I love the character in Richie Tozier so much in the book, and while Finn Wolfhard wasn't quite as fun as young Richie as Seth Green was, Bill Hader is the better adult Richie, and the slight change to his story fit well. It made the film for me.

I wasn't all-in on that climactic battle (for the many quips about Stephen King endings, this part doesn't exactly feel much better), but the part that comes after, the more human side of the story? That was lovely.

Pennywise though? Considering how central the character is to the story, it surprised me how underutilized it is over the course of two films. When done right (the kill under the bleachers is as close to the heartbreaking meanness of the books as the films get) it's great, but there's a lot of underwhelming CG jump scares that suck the life out of some genuinely creepy and tense moments. I like this Pennywise, but it needed backing with something meatier.

I can't say I'm disappointed with Chapter Two. Like the first chapter, it does a lot more right in portraying the story than it does wrong, and the changes are generally good. It definitely misses the mark a fair bit in terms of its horror, and the final showdown is actually worse than the original the more I think about it. Thing is, adapting this book is such a complex problem, and the fact anyone got this close to nailing it while putting a fresh spin on it is admirable.