You just can't remake perfection
Review of Road house (2024) by pstergos: 👎 5.0/10
Road House 1989 is such a lighting in a bottle of cheesy cinema that any attempt to redo it is in a horrible catch-22 situation. You need the throat ripping, the fucking guys in prison, the explosions with amazing comic timing, a polar bear falling on someone....but trying to do all that again would just be a bit flat. So the remake can do that or try to blaze it's own trail.
It does...well, neither.
I mean it is a vastly different movie than the 1989 one but is it really? All the broad strokes are there, they just give things a different coat of paint. There's still a dude named Dalton who cleans up a bar. There's still an evil businessman wanting the town who brings in some awesome fighter who may or may not have fucked guys in prison. And both tells us that in a fight nobody wins.
But the things it does do different...its pointless. There's more of a plot sure but it just bogs the movie down. A legit charm of the original was Patrick Swayze wondering the town and making friends with the locals. But there's really none of it, sure there's people but you don't really get a sense of that. And any extra plot is just explanations on things we don't need to really know. Like why does Dalton being in the UFC matters...speaking of.
Dalton being in the UFC is an actual interesting direction that could lead to interesting paths. Like the real UFC prides itself on nobody dying so Dalton killing someone in a cage could've led to some good character building. It doesn't take any of them but the idea was sound. But let's face it, take away that backstory and does anything change with Dalton? It works as well with the Patrick Swayze backstory which to say is there was none.
Now that Ive established comparing the Road Houses is a dumb attempt. What about in a vaccuum?
Still doesn't work.
What you have outside of its past is just another boring action film. I guess Jake Gylenhall has a germ of an interesting idea of being the soft-spoken and apologetic asskicker but it's kinda boring. And Conor McGregor is a hoot for three minutes and then gets boring real fast.
And then there's the fight scenes. They actually had a good filming idea with making CGI doubles so they can do actual strikes. I get it on the sense of speeding up filming and making the fights more realistic looking. It just looks bad and once you see the changeover from human to CGI, you can't unsee it and it's there. Just mocking your vision.
And the biggest reason why I can never recommend Road House 2024....Post Malone is shirtless.