Spider-Man, Spider-Man...fails whatever Batman does
Review of Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026) by pstergos: 👎 5.0/10
Spider-Man: No Way Home was probably the biggest movie event of COVID. The brightest light in a post-Thanos MCU after stumbling at every possibly angle trying to make Kang a thing even real life. It had the biggest ace up its sleeve with getting Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield and their respective villains back. A team-up so amazing that it reignited passion in a stagnant universe, even for a brief moment. Then the question becomes...what comes next?
Not a good movie is the answer Brand New Day has come up with. For the highest grossing movie ever in America, you would think there was something to justify this love and it success. Anything at all! Even an actual well-crafted movie would have justify all this. Instead all we are left with is Spider-Man being officially too big to fail. Instead, we get a half-ass setup for X-men that doesn't really justify itself.
Why all this? Well, it makes Spider-Man the least interesting character in his own movie. His story is "well, stuff is happening without rhyme or reason, time to check Instagram!" And then I realize why it feels so off. Spidey wants to be Batman! He broods in a lair like Batman...only poor! He's a loner....like Batman! He even has ethically dubious software to track crime! Like Batman did and that became a big plotline about the ethics of using such stuff that lead to Morgan Freeman walking away from an exploding computer bank. With Spider-Man, it's an "Oh you rapscallion, I'll pretend you didn't say it." and it's just such a bad taste. Spider-Man and Batman are like the antithesis of each other so one trying to be the other feels, looks and is wrong.
But surely this is a forgivable thing, right? A well-made movie can cover up a lot of flaws. If only it was actually well-made or even had a story. This is a prime example of "Well, that happened" without much rhyme or reason. It's so very clumsy. It's like we only get the middle of a scene for every scene. There's no flow to any of it, it's all things that happen with nothing to make us care for any of it.
But there has to be good things about it, right? Sure, not one of them is Spider-Man. I mean Tom Holland tries his best, he just has nothing to support him except the very few times he has a scene with MJ. You can feel how disgusting in love Tom and Zendaya are with each other when they interact. So that's something. It's fun to see the new Black Widow and Hulk doing things even it's all pointless on their end. The Punisher is the biggest surprise though, he actually gets a story, character development and an arc! It makes me wonder what would've happen if it was The Punisher: Brand New Day feature Spider-Man. Jon Berthnal and Tom Holland have good chemistry too even if the movie attempts to make Punisher and Spidey a wacky tag team that hates each other fall flat.
In the end, what we have here is...well, this may be the worst Spider-Man movie. Say what you want about the Andrew Garfield movies but those had stories! They were bad ones but they existed! Even Spider-Man 3 had occasional moments of brilliance. This is dumb, stupid sloppity slop and there should be a sense of shame within everyone for allowing this to happen.