PM2 is More Detailed, but Less Endearing
Review of Practical Magic 2 (2026) by reel_tinseltine: 👍 4.7/10
I didn't rewatch "Practical Magic" before seeing "Practical Magic 2". Nope. I watched it for the first time! I know. How had I never seen it? I've loved witches since "Bewitched". I can watch "Charmed" episodes over and over, and "The Witches of Eastwick" is a hoot. So you'd think "Practical Magic" would have been right up my alley. But despite its cult following, I have to say... I didn't think it was very good. The pacing, beats and tones were all over the place. It felt disjointed, and by the end I was basically thinking, "Well, that didn't break the curse." And I was right!
Fortunately, I like the sequel better. The Owens women are still living in that impossibly charming seaside town, in that impossibly enchanting house. Sally (Sandra Bullock) is now twice a widow, while Gilly (Nicole Kidman) is still hot and still single. Sally's daughters, Kylie (Joey King) and Antonia (Maisie Williams), would technically be old enough that we should probably be following their daughters' love lives by now, but let's not get into the mathematics of aging Hollywood actresses. Suffice it to say, Kylie is in college and Antonia is a medical intern.
The writers seem to have taken a little more care with the story. The plot hangs together better, maybe a bit long, but the tonal shifts aren't quite as jarring. Perhaps some of the sisterly moments between Sally and Gilly feel a little forced. These moments are more organic in the original, hence why I think it's beloved by so many.
Neither of Sally's daughters knows anything about magic. Sally's decree has kept the family secret intact, despite the girls maintaining close relationships with their aunt and great-aunts, played once again by Stockard Channing and Dianne Wiest. It's Kylie's turn to fall in love only for the curse to rear its ugly head again. Having no choice but to fill the girls in on their history as Owens witches - Kylie takes off like a bat out of hell to England to find a way to break the curse, not understanding that she's courting dark magic, she's not prepared to fight.
And then there's Lee Pace. Ridiculously sexy as Sally's British love interest, but I kinda thought she and Gilly should both be attracted to him, throw in a little sisterly rivalry. Not enough to hijack the plot, just a beat or two.
In the end, I'm not in love with either the original or the sequel, but I'm always for witches, romance, sisterhood, close family and a house I would happily move into tomorrow.