Chris Pine should never be allowed to direct again

Review of Poolman (2024) by kcookandcatsco: 👎 2.0/10

What a calamitous, disastrous narrative failure this was!

I barely have words for it.

Thankfully, I tweeted a bunch, so we can dip into those.

I didn't even post once about Poolman until I was 23 minutes into it, and checked the scrub bar, thinking it had been maybe 6 or 8 minutes' worth of story.

Nope!

I think this movie is meant to be a loving homage to Chinatown and other LA-focused films, but honestly, it just insults their memories and the audience by alluding to them over and over again. Like, don't watch this. Watch Chinatown again. That's a good movie.

Most of Poolman is just long, loving, luxurious close-ups of writer, director and star, Chris Pine. This is the most Chris Pine that's ever been in a film, and Jesus, I think I might hate him!

I certainly hated seeing his face fill the goddamned frame every 60 or 90 seconds.

Do you like it when actors stare right down the barrel at you? They love to do it. Do you like it when they do it?

This isn't a story. I'm not sure anyone involved knows what a story is, or how to write characters that resonate and give 'authentic.' This feels like something Wes Anderson would have written, but declined to film, maybe when he was in junior high.

Let me tell you something, friend. You are owed a better story than this film can provide. Avoid it at all costs. It's too late for me, but save yourself...