Mary Elizabeth Winstead is the coolest 🤩

Review of The Thing (2011) by kcookandcatsco: 👎 5.0/10

I think people should relax about this movie.

I'd always heard it's one of the most disappointing and worst movies ever, and it's become clear that that's only in comparison to the 1982 John Carpenter The Thing (which is, of course, not the original; that would be Howard Hawks's unwatchable The Thing From Another World, 1951).

This is a pretty unobjectionable movie, except for a couple of wonky bits, and if it were, like, its own thing and not beholden to the legacy of Carpenter's The Thing (one of the greatest films ever made), I don't think people would mind this so much.

This is an odd side note of my personal experience; I watched this free on YouTube, and it was the NBC Universal TV version, with all the swears cut out and even the subtitles were blurred when they were subtitling swears. Lol.

There were a bunch of moments that I found to be quite effective or even enthralling. I think the acting was quite good, the pacing was pretty solid. It's just generally a pretty-okay, fine flick, except that it's supposed to be a follow-up to The Thing (1982).

The script sure isn't great, though! It feels first-draft-y. I unlocked a new screenwriting pet peeve watching this, which is always great news for everyone, I'm sure (a new thing that irritates me!):

All the alien spaceship stuff felt way out of place in a The Thing film, and also felt plagiarized from The X-Files movie from 15ish years earlier.

You could safely miss this one. It adds nothing, really, but it is a pretty good vehicle for Mary Elizabeth Winstead, and for a movie free on YouTube, I found it totally worthwhile and not bad.

Would not say I recommend it, but I've always been warned away from it, and that was silly, I think.