Neither fish nor fowl

Review of The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012) by salvius23: 👍 3.5/5

The Hobbit is a children's book in a way LotR is not, and I wish Jackson had gone all-in on making these films match the tone of the LotR films, and left out some of the more whimsical things like the stone giants hurling boulders at each other (IIRC, such giants are never mentioned elsewhere in the legendarium, and the Watsonian explanation is that they were one of Bilbo's embellishments).

Either that or gone all-in on making a straight-up children's movie, but then they'd have had to to cut out all of the added material about what Gandalf was up to when he was off-screen in the book, and pared the whole thing down to probably a single movie.