Mixed tone

Review of The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013) by salvius23: 👍 3.5/5

Continues the tonal problems of the first film, in that it seemingly can't fully commit to being either epic or whimsical. Some bits are very effective (the dwarves first entry into Erebor, Bilbo talking to Smaug), and other bits are just silly (much of the river-barrel action scene).