Where "Supergirl" stumbles is in its relationships...

Review of Supergirl (2026) by reel_tinseltine: 👎 4.5/10

I always want female-led superhero movies to soar. We need more of them, not fewer. So I was rooting for SUPERGIRL from the moment the lights went down. In the end, though, it's just entertaining enough.

Walking out of the theater, my immediate thought—which I'm sure I'm not alone in having—was: this is basically a female John Wick dropped into a Star Wars movie. It's a galaxy-spanning revenge quest, with colorful alien worlds, bounty hunters, bar fights, oversized weapons, and enough interplanetary mayhem to make you think it's going well, but mid-point I found myself saying this is missing something.

It's not the fault of Milly Alcock, although she's not quite as funny as her cameo in the end credits of SUPERMAN (2025) she's still incredibly watchable. I love Kara's perpetually disheveled look and her rough-around-the-edges, almost dude-ish demeanor. She's not polished or eager to be anyone's symbol of hope, and that's an interesting contrast to Superman. I was disappointed to discover Alcock is Australian. I used to think it was charming whenever I learned an actor from Britain or Australia had nailed an American accent, but now I'm ready to ask: can we hire a few more American actors? Especially for something as quintessentially American as a superhero movie.

Where "Supergirl" stumbles is in its relationships. The film depends on Kara forming meaningful bonds with Ruthye Marye Knoll (Eve Ridley), while Lobo (Jason Momoa) injects some lovable chaos into the mix. Unfortunately, I never really felt that chemistry or sense of found family. Compare that with Superman (2025), where Clark's relationships with Mister Terrific, Lois Lane, Green Lantern, Jimmy Olsen—even the delightfully unruly Krypto—created an infectious team dynamic. Here, Krypto mostly feels like a convenient plot device rather than the hilarious scene-stealer he was before.

Craig Gillespie gives the film a gritty, lived-in cosmic aesthetic that looks terrific on the big screen (I saw it in IMAX). The production design, visual effects, creature work, and alien environments create a believable universe that's both grimy and grand, while the action sequences are kinetic enough to keep the revenge story moving. And yet, we'll have forgotten this movie happened by August.