Star Trek: The Motion Picture Review
Review of Star Trek: The Motion Picture (1979) by applescruff909: 👍 9.0/10
One of my favorite background watches when I don't want to have to think too much and simply want to see pretty space stuff and hear excellent Jerry Goldsmith music, but also one of my favorites to immerse myself in. I've reached the point where I can say with no hesitation that I love this film.
It's like a visual symphonic experience, featuring characters everyone recognizes, and it's increasingly rewarding, the more times I watch it. The Wrath of Khan or The Voyage Home would make better entry points for someone new to the series, but this one of the good ones, and has gradually become my favorite.
The common criticisms of this film, particularly its slow start, are certainly valid, but ST:TMP still works for me, exceptionally well, in fact. I understand viewers dismissing it as slow or boring, or even referring to it as Star Trek: The Special Effect, but this is an amazing film, and it must have been so wonderful in 1979 for fans of the long since cancelled TV series to see their favorite characters, and their favorite starship, on the big screen for the first time, even if it didn't play out in a way they were expecting.
This is the most cinematic of all the Trek films, especially the originals. Most of the others in the TOS/TNG series feel like two or three part TV episodes released as movies, probably by design. Some are great, some less so. The Wrath of Khan, often lauded as the movie the fans wanted in the first place, was made on a much tighter budget after TMP went way over, and it utilized more TV production techniques, including the use of a largely TV-experienced crew. I love that both approaches resulted in excellent work. The Motion Picture is just that, a Motion Picture in the grandest sense. It's of a certain pedigree, with a renowned director, Robert Wise (editor of Citizen Kane, director of The Day the Earth Stood Still, West Side Story, The Sound of Music, and The Haunting, among many others) at the helm. He deserves significant credit for being able to manage all of the egos with their hands in the creative process, especially Gene Roddenberry, who was notorious for being difficult to work for/with.
MAJOR kudos and an MVP designation go to the great Douglas Trumbull, who had previously worked on the visual effects of 2001: A Space Odyssey and Close Encounters of the Third Kind, as well as The Andromeda Strain, also directed by Robert Wise. He stepped in on this film, saw the sorry shape of the visual effects, tossed them, and turned this into one of the most beautiful spectacles the film industry and the sci-fi genre has ever given us. The Enterprise 1701 ("No bloody A, B, C, or D") has never looked better than it does here, and the scope of the space sequences is breathtaking.
And that score! It's among Jerry Goldsmith's best, and my favorite of all of the films'. I'm a sucker for a good overture. Since ST:TMP (and Disney's The Black Hole released a couple of weeks later), they have sadly been fairly rare. The sweeping score is one of the film's most celebrated features, and it says a lot that the main theme from this film was later repurposed as the theme from Star Trek: The Next Generation.
It's more philosophical and cerebral than most casual moviegoers are comfortable with, but that, in my mind, really is pure Star Trek, and it's a feature, not a bug. My main criticism is that I wish some of the lengthy visual effects sequences, such as the (admittedly gorgeous) shuttle flight around the Enterprise at the beginning, could have been tightened in favor of more character development and interaction. Some of the pacing issues were tightened up and improved upon in the Director's Edition, which is the one most widely available today, and the one upon which I base this review. The interpersonal relationships among the crew are a significant part of what makes Star Trek so endearing as a franchise, and the crew of the original series gelled so beautifully together, it was a bit of a let down to see so much less interaction among them, even though the film managed to get all of them back together- something they were unable to do a few years prior on The Animated Series. The new characters of Decker (future disgrace Stephen Collins) and Ilia (the extraordinary and lovely Persis Khambatta) add both romantic and existential intrigue. Ilia is one of the Great Women of the franchise, from where I sit, and she is absolutely iconic in this film.
Another common criticism I hear essentially boils down to Kirk being kind of an asshole in this film, mostly due to the way he bulldozes/bullies his way into command of the Enterprise and pushes Decker to the side. In true Star Trek fashion, though, he eventually sees the error in his ways, as he does with his assumption that the big "thing" coming towards Earth must be destroyed. Look, everybody! A character arc!
Another prevailing critique is that there's no relatable villain (with a face) that we're up against. That doesn't bother me in the slightest. Apollo 13 didn't have a villain, and it was still terrific! Facing the unknown, going "where no one has gone before," is a considerable challenge in and of itself, and can be exhilarating. Villains can be awesome (e.g. Khan, Kruge, Chang, The Borg Queen), but they aren't always necessary to make a compelling film. The mystery of V'ger and the reveal of its origin and objective is truly special, and it's top-shelf science fiction.
Star Trek: The Motion Picture may not be the action-packed adventure some fans expected or would prefer, but it stands as a bold, thoughtful, visually stunning, and ultimately satisfying entry in the franchise. Its slower pace and emphasis on wonder over conflict set it apart, making it feel more like a true sci-fi epic than just another installment in the series. While it's not without flaws, its ambition, artistry, and thematic depth make it a film worth revisiting, especially for those willing to embrace its meditative approach to exploration and discovery, "Out there...that-a-way."