The Dark Knight Review
Review of The Dark Knight (2008) by applescruff909: π 8.0/10
Batmen Ranked: #4. Its highs (Operation Sky Hook, the chases, almost every scene with Heath Ledger) are higher than those of Batman Begins, but its lows (the overdrawn and overacted "ferry dilemma", the miscasting of Maggie Gyllenhaal, the subplot with an employee threatening to out Bruce Wayne as Batman) are also lower.
Part of the lower rating is due to it being one of the most thinly veiled pieces of Patriot Act propaganda of the entire Bush administration. From a British director, no less. Fucking gross.
Christian Bale is a wonderful actor, but his Batman voice is ridiculous and embarrassing. Otherwise, no notes, other than about things his character does and he, the actor, is not responsible for. He's always perfect as Bruce Wayne.
I don't know how to explain this, but I'm not sure if Maggie Gyllenhaal is good or not as Rachel. Something doesn't work for me, and I can't put my finger on it. Probably comes down to how her character's written, which is puzzling because I liked Katie Holmes in the first one. Rachel was nerfed, and frankly, kind of annoying here, and Maggie Gyllenhaal was not a great fit. She seemed like she didn't want to be in the movie.
Heath Ledger yada yada legendary yada yada. Nothing to add to that discussion.
Aaron Eckhart (who was in everything for a while back then) is outstanding as Harvey Dent. I always felt like he was undeservedly left out of the acclaim this received upon release. The FX on his face are well done and very gnarly. Get this man some Visine!
I'm calling my shot here. We will never get a better Gordon than Gary Oldman. Jeffrey Wright is also awesome in the role, but Oldman is next-level amazing.
Morgan Freeman is well into his not-trying-for-any-awards-anymore phase when he just played "a Morgan Freeman type" in everything after his excellent turn in Million Dollar Baby. Full disclosure: Lucius reminds me of my ex father in-law, and not in a good way, so I'm biased here. The smug smile and nod when the unethical and grossly illegal surveillance tools he was just complicit in using on citizens blows up is supposed to let the audience know everything's okay now, but the man still helped a mentally unwell vigilante spy on innocent people. Fuck Lucius.
It's too long. The boat sequence is not suspenseful and feels like it lasts for ages. The sub-plot of the employee threatening to out Bruce Wayne is obnoxious. It sometimes feels like two movies smooshed together, in a Spider-Man 3 way. (That's bad.)
Still, it's entertaining, though it's not as briskly paced as it felt the first time or two. I get its status as a classic, but it's far from perfect, at least for me. I'm grateful that it brought some legitimacy to the genre. Batman Beginswas really close, but it took a minute for some to warm up to it. To be clear, I still enjoy The Dark Knight, very much. It's just never been at the top of my list like it is for so many others. I can't fault people at all for enjoying it more than I do.