Superman Returns Review

Review of Superman Returns (2006) by applescruff909: 👎 4.0/10

Brandon Routh pays beautiful homage to Christopher Reeve, especially in the oft-ignored Clark Kent persona. He's the reason to see this. I genuinely enjoyed him here.

Kate Bosworth is fine as yet another underdeveloped Lois Lane. Given better material, she could've been the best Lois since Margot Kidder.

Parker Posey is at her Parker Posey-est; the quality of her performance is dependent on what the viewer thinks of Parker Posey in general.

The Brando footage is interesting , but by no means saves the movie. It was used better, along with the John Williams score, in the powerful trailer, which the film does not live up to.

Kevin Spacey absolutely sucks as Lex Luthor in what should have been a home run performance. There have been 3 good Luthors so far: Gene Hackman, Michael Rosenbaum, and Clancy Brown (though I'm holding out hope for Nicholas Hoult in Superman '25). Spacey's bad, and he should feel bad.

Speaking of bad, the story is pretty weak, which is made worse by the exorbitant runtime. I've added it to my list of Movies That Have No Business Being Over 2 Hours Long. Moreover, Superman As Christ Figure™ is rammed down our throats, and the subplot with the child just pisses me off.

Superman is way OP in this one, too, if a bullet doesn't so much as make his eyeball twitch. The use of his powers is usually limited to "Ohhh shit, will he be able to lift [whatever heavy thing]?" (Yes. Yes he can, even when it's made of Kryptonite and stabbing into him.) I liked what he did about the falling glass after the plane crash, but otherwise, there wasn't much to write home about. The VFX themselves are fine, but they alone don't make a good movie.

Question: How did they end up getting the IV into him, if all the needles kept breaking? I call bullshit.

Quentin Tarantino went on record about how much he loved this film, but I haven't done enough coke to see what he saw in it.

In summary, go watch the good Christopher Reeve films instead. This was a big, expensive disappointment.