American Beauty Review

Review of American Beauty (1999) by applescruff909: 👎 3.0/10

Stop taping her, you creep! She asked you nicely.

Now I'm mad at her. DTMFA, young lady.

American Beauty has aged almost hilariously poorly, but it also wasn't a very good film to begin with. It's a Fisher Price My First Artsy-Fartsy Film™ for many folks from my generation (as was Fight Club that same year), and it's never sat all that well with me.

I've tried again a few times over the years to like it, but I just can't, even though I understand why people praise(d) it. I think the biggest problem is that I really can't stomach Alan Ball's on-the-nose, predatory writing (see also: Towelhead). Sam Mendes directed it about as well as it could be directed, I suppose, but I simply don't like it and never really have.

My criticism is not informed by what has happened with Kevin Spacey since the film's release. Admittedly, he and Annette Bening are quite good in it, all things considered. I just hate that it's taken Spacey's real life accusations to get people to notice that Lester isn't a good person. None of the main characters is a particularly good person in this film.

To those who do enjoy it, I say good for you, and I mean that. I'm glad it works for somebody; it simply doesn't for me.