Star Wars: Episode I β The Phantom Menace Review
Review of Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace (1999) by applescruff909: π 3.0/10
It's difficult to express just how hard up we were for new Star Wars in 1998-1999. It had been gone from the entertainment landscape through much of the 1990s, except for occasional airings on cable TV and VHS re-releases. The 1997 Special Editions, while not to everybody's liking, certainly whetted our appetites for whatever Lucasfilm was going to give us next.
Then he gave us The Phantom Menace. (cough)
Hmm... Well, it... I just... (long exhale)
It's not very good, is it?
There's not much for me to say that hasn't been said by other disappointed people, but I can add that I threw the last half hour of the movie on for background watching recently, and even it is pretty boring.
The trailer for TPM was legendary. It was the first one I downloaded from the internet and watched over and over (LONG before YouTube existed). The anticipation was intense, and in retrospect, it would have been hard for it to ever live up to the expectations that trailer gave us.
So many things annoy me about it, though.
Anakin and Jar-Jar have their successes due to dumb (and I mean DUMB) luck.
Whatever the queen and the royal guards are doing during the "climax" is boring. (Trade relations and treaties: You know, for kids!)
And sadly, even the Jedi battle with Darth Maul isn't as good as it felt at the time. With the help of some spectacular stunt work and especially "Duel of the Fates" playing under it, the fight is still the most watchable part of the film, but the scene itself doesn't hold up well. Why set up Jedi Speed Runningβ’ at the beginning if you're just going to have Obi-Wan stopped repeatedly by seemingly useless force fields on his way to giving Darth Maul a good slicey-slicing? While the last bit of the fight is exciting, I kind of wish Obi-Wan had been a little rawer when he went after Maul, all pissed off about Qui-Gon. Instead we got more of the ultra-choreographed fencing ballet, which looks cool and all, but could use some variety. I'm convinced Qui-Gon had a death wish. That wound would be survivable in 2020s Star Wars. It was a dick move to make Obi-Wan promise that he'd train the brat he couldn't stand for the rest of the movie, thus dooming most of the Jedi. Idiot.
All that said, Liam Neeson and especially Ewan McGregor were the right men for their roles. I just wish Lucas had more people saying "No" to him along the way.
β’ Gunga City: Boring β’ People, Jedi and otherwise, sitting in semi-circles and blathering on monotonously about trade routes, tariffs, people apparently dying off-screen: Also boring. Can we see* some of the dying people so we can establish the lady with the mysterious decoy as a reliable narrator? Anakin's surprisingly nice house: Unlikely for a fucking slave.* β’ Anakin making a protocol droid, of all things, to help his desert slave mother: Asinine and forced. 3PO is more useless than ever. Is this slave going to be throwing banquets or official gatherings or something? So dumb. β’ Midichlorians: Get outta here. β’ Shmi Skywalker: I never trusted her. The Virgin Birth bullshit has yet to get a straight, satisfying explanation that doesn't require reading books I don't want to, nor should I have to to read. Even fellow Christ figure Superman had a dad. β’ Relying on "Legends" literature or several seasons of cartoons that I don't have the spoons for doesn't strengthen this piece of shit prequel trilogy. In fact, the success of shows like Clone Wars offer proof that the prequels in their cinematic form needed a lot of retconning and course correction in order to make any sense at all. β’ Pod racing: Boring and overlong. Great time for a refill/bathroom break. It also pulled off the impressive feat of making the usually hilarious Greg Proops not funny in the slightest. β’ Pod racing bet negotiations: Even more boring. Wait a minute, did Qui-Gon cheat at that dice roll? He's lucky the Hutts didn't put his head in a vise. Force wielding degenerate gambler series when? β’ Imagining Watto blowing his brains out after he "lost [his] everything": Priceless π β’ The reveal that the real queen was the one sent into the desert after cleaning up an astromech droid: Unsurprising to everyone but the dumb kid. β’ Everything to do with Jar-Jar, his mannerisms, and his speech patterns: Unfunny and offensive. The fact that there are people who in ironically love that character is all the proof I need that society, if it ever stood, has crumbled. Nothing against Ahmed Best. This is all on Lucas and the spineless bimbi who didn't know how to say no to him (looking at you, Rick McCallum).
I'm being generous with the stars I'm giving this. I also admit that I saw it repeatedly in the cinema where I worked during the summer of 1999. Retrospective dislike aside, it was and is always fun to see new Star Wars in a theater with a packed house.