The Godfather Part III Review

Review of The Godfather Part III (1990) by applescruff909: 👍 9.0/10

(Author's note: This review is for the 1991 home video version, which is 8 minutes longer than the theatrical cut- which I didn't see- and not the re-cut "Coda" version, which I'd give 3.5 stars. It's leaner, but also kind of sloppily done. Calling it The Death of Michael Corleone and cutting out his actual death was a strange choice. Anyhow, onto my review!)

Godfather III is better than its reputation dictates. It lives deep in the shadow of the previous films, as do pretty much all modern crime movies, but it's a perfectly serviceable film, in spite of its shortcomings.

First of all, Sofia Coppola is fine, considering she had next to no time to prepare for the role after Winona Ryder dropped out. Feeling out of place in this film does service to Mary Corleone, who absolutely did not belong in her father's underworld. Her tragedy is on multiple fronts. I'll grant that her dialogue is pretty wooden, but her dad could've written her part better and/or directed her better.

A lot of the problems come back to Francis Ford Coppola. He made it as a cash grab for too little money, relied too much on nostalgia, and wrote an unnecessarily convoluted story. The scenes involving Michael's business dealings with Immobiliare and the Vatican are almost always momentum killers, but when this film gels, it really works.

The villains, even the well-acted ones, are sometimes fairly one dimensional. Joe Mantegna brings charisma to anotherwise dull John Gotti-esque gangster type. Big kudos to Eli Wallach for making the most of a somewhat flimsy character with no prior depiction or development in the series. He understood the assignment. Archbishop Gilday, Frederick Keinzig, and Don Lucchesi don't have the presence of, say, a Virgil Solozzo or a Hyman Roth, but they get the job done.

Andy Garcia does what he can to bring life to Vincent, but his character arc from Vinnie Mancini the Mafia hood to Don Vincenzo Corleone doesn't feel natural or earned. The often criticized incestuous subplot doesn't translate to film as well as it might have in a novel, though it does work as the beginning of Mary's path into oblivion.

Then there's Anthony, who should have been a much more interesting, layered character, but instead serves only as a plot device to 1. get Michael and Kay talking again and 2. give the movie a reason to go to an on-the-nose Sicilian opera for the climax.

The Michael and Kay scenes can be a little melodramatic at times (more on that in a moment), but they do a lot of the work in making this feel like a Godfather film, keeping it grounded in family dynamics and continuing their troubled relationship in a mostly believable fashion.

Okay, back to the point about melodrama. Michael, y'all. My feelings on Al Pacino's performance are mixed. He is unquestionably a remarkable actor, and ome of his scenes are absolutely note perfect and truly feel like Michael. Other moments, however, veer into caricature. He often goes for loud, over-the-top intensity instead of the subtle, shimmering power he showed in the first two films. Coppola's decision to give him a crew cut and make him a phony-baloney philanthropist trying to convince the world that he's a nice guy is awkward, and that dissonance bleeds into the performance. I have a feeling Coppola and Puzo were aware of this, hence Kay's very strong dressing-down dialogue pointing out Michael's hypocrisy, which hits hard.

For me, some of the melodrama works, like Michael's plea to God that he "will sin no more" and his vulnerable breakdown during his confession to Cardinal Lamberto of decades worth of his horrible deeds. Other scenes don't quite work, such as his screaming fit during his diabetic attack, which was fine until becoming unintentionally comical with his overperformed "Don't run from thunder! Harmless noise! Fredo! FREDO!!!" part. Yikes. Still, Pacino carries the weight of his character's guilt, regret, and longing, and the opera sequence toward the end gives him some magnificent moments of genuine tragic resonance, culminating in that silent scream on the steps. Some might criticize it as overdoing it, but for me, it's devastating, as if in a few short seconds, he's forced to revisit every wrong decision he's ever made, and face the tragic consequences laid before him. He can't breathe or speak, until finally, he expresses the weight of his guilt and grief in a gut-wrenching, anguished cry into the night. It's truly splendid acting. Knowing that Michael has to live with that grief until the end of his days is downright poetic.

Then we have Connie, finally coming into her own as a Corleone. I have a soft spot for Talia Shire, and I enjoy watching her become a bloodthirsty matriarch after being a victimized doormat for most of the first two films. She's given a great part here, showing loyalty and care for her ailing, jaded brother while also stepping up and making difficult, sometimes horrible decisions for the family. Connie contains multitudes here, and the character is better for it. She, like Michael in the first film, eventually becomes hardened by circumstance after beginning the story as an innocent. I honestly wouldn't have minded more scenes about her character development. Some would say her character's transformation is also not earned, but her performance during the opera sequence, voyeuristically watching a man die, then giving one of the coldest looks this side of a Kubrick film, is satisfying to watch.

One of the most common criticisms is that Robert Duvall did not return as Tom Hagen due to the film's budget not allowing for his salary demands. I have no doubt that he would have been excellent in the third film, but I also have trouble imagining exactly what his role would have been.

Ultimately, it's an interesting epilogue for the series, and one I'm happy to watch every so often, probably about 1 out of ever 3 or 4 times I watch the other two. I completely understand it being a divisive film, but I'm rather fond of it.

The Godfather Part IIImay not reach the heights of its predecessors, but as an admittedly flawed, funereal closing chapter, it reminds us why the Corleone saga remains unforgettable.