Midnight Cowboy Review
Review of Midnight Cowboy (1969) by applescruff909: 👍 10.0/10
Easily in my top 3 or 4, Midnight Cowboy is a very important film to me, and probably the most important "gateway" movie for me when I was in my early teens back in the 1990s. Faith No More had done an amazing cover of its iconic theme by John Barry on 1992's Angel Dust, my favorite album of all time, and it piqued my curiosity about the film. I couldn't find it in any video stores, but thankfully a friend from school was able to tape (yes, tape) it off of Cinemax for me. Those were the days, man.
I hadn't seen anything like it before. The X rating it initially received was meant to indicate it was for adults only, but there I was taking it all in, practically on repeat, at age 14. There was so much I didn't "get" on my first viewing. I remember my dad coming into the room during the Factory party sequence the first time I watched it. Of course, this was when the movie fully embraced its will to be weird (my parents had an incredible ability to walk in at exactly the wrong moment), and I said, trying to save face, "This was normal before this part!" (No, it wasn't.) To his credit, Dad stayed in the room and watched the rest of it with me without judgment or admonishment. I grew up very sheltered, but they were good about letting me experience the movies and music I wanted.
As I grew older and matured, so did my feelings about the film. Perhaps the thing I've identified with most, all the way back to that first watch, was my curiosity about living in different times and places, as well as the way I feel for outsiders, strays, and people who dream bigger than their circumstances allow. That's me! It depicted both the grit and the tenderness at play in an uneasy relationship that turned into a love story. Not exactly a sexual love, but certainly a familial love, in that these two men relied on and took care of each other as best they could. I have a lot of respect for films that balance despair with flashes of warmth and humanity. It's full of nuance, and richly rewards repeat viewings.
It's a bleak film, but it remembers to include a few laughs, including the absolute treat that is the "Florida Fantasy" sequence, along the way. It respects its viewers and trusts them enough to offer flashes of emotion and memory without explanation. Attentive viewers will find their way through some of the more puzzling elements, especially regarding Joe's childhood in Texas, but it's not going to hold your hand.
One of its other great strengths is its willingness to present marginalized sexuality without turning preachy or passing judgment. While it probably sensationalized audiences upon release, I admire how it treats sex work, same-sex encounters, childhood trauma, loneliness, emotional vulnerability, and unconventional intimacy as realities of its characters' lives instead of edgy plot device gimmicks. For a film released in its time, that was really a remarkable feat.
The film, like me, is a bit of a misfit. It functions as a character study, a social drama, a tragedy, a social commentary, a friendship story, and in retrospect, a groundbreaking work in queer cinema. Joe Buck and Rico "Ratso" Rizzo are among the most memorable pairings in American film history, and their relationship, like the film, doesn't fit neatly into a single category. Their relationship is built upon necessity, dependency, frustration, desperation, affection, and ultimately genuine care for one another.
Its Oscar win and other accolades solidified the dawn of a new cinematic era, bringing a European flair to a story about the fallacy of the American Dream™ and the unlikely bonds we forge in our most desperate times.
It's not for everybody, to be sure, but I've never seen a film that better lived up to its tagline: "Everything you've heard about Midnight Cowboy...is true." Some films are important because they changed cinema; others are important because they still resonate decades later, even for people who weren't around when it was new. Midnight Cowboy is both.