Stays too close to a source text not written as a drama, so a lot of static talking, but its stern Jesus gets the message across better than in any ot
Review of The Gospel According to St. Matthew (1964) by cinema_mokum: 👍 7.0/10
The movie for which most fans are eagerly awaiting the sequel, one that never seems to arrive.
Okay, so this is a film adaptation of the Gospel according to Matthew in the most direct sense: all the lines spoken are taken directly from the Bible. Pasolini did mix things up a and left some parts out. Even so, it’s still a book that wasn’t written as a play, let alone a movie script, so there are a lot of rather static scenes in which Jesus preaches his message. We see the Spaniard Enrique Irazoqui, but hear Enrico Salerno, because this is an Italian film from the 1960s, when they didn’t make a big deal out of casting foreign actors and then dubbing them. That just makes it feel even more distant.
Still, it’s a reasonable successful film, even though the first part—covering Jesus’s birth and childhood—doesn’t really flow well, and the entire John the Baptist storyline with Salome and all that feels a bit out of place. But that was probably too juicy for Pasolini to leave out. To be honest: I’d always include it, too.
It’s only when the adult Jesus begins to preach his message that the film really gets going. Pasolini strings all of Jesus’s important speeches together, effectively conveying the radical nature of the Gospel: society is rotten to the core, plagued by decadence and hypocrisy, and the only solution is to leave everything behind for an ascetic life in the service of God (camel, eye of the needle). You will be persecuted for this, and you will likely fail as well, whether or not the rooster crows three times. In my view, an atheist raised in a very liberal Dutch Reformed family, the marxist Pasolini manages to create a kind of condensed version of the Gospel that conveys the central message far more effectively than the often woolly Christian attempts to do so.
The stern Jesus also fits well with the film’s raw tone. In my view, Pasolini effectively captures first-century Israel as a somewhat shabby, barren region—a lost corner of the Roman Empire. He also cast people plucked right off the street, apparently selected for their distinctive facial features.
Somewhat surprising for a film made by a socialist is the lack of glorification of ordinary people, such as the apostles, who are primarily shown as well meaning failures. Pasolini does seem to side with Judas when he gets angry about Jesus being anointed with expensive oil—money that could have been given to the poor instead (though perhaps that’s just my projection, since I actually agree with Judas on that point). But then it's another thing to betray him to the authorities for that; Judas as the original Karen. In the end, the film is, above all, a tirade against the ruling elite. As far as I could tell from a quick search, that's accurate to the Gospel according to Matthew, but it was also a hallmark of the only other Pasolini film I’ve ever seen, the otherwise completely different Salò, or the 120 Days of Sodom.