This is the only good one π€
Review of Star Wars: Episode IV β A New Hope (1977) by kcookandcatsco: π 10.0/10
But what a good one!
You can tell this is the good one, because it only gets better with rewatches. It's a resonant, iconic, archetypal story, and it sparked the imaginations of generations of writers and artists for a reason.
I've done some reading lately that's attempting to rewrite history regarding Marcia Lucas saving Star Wars in the edit. Don't believe the hype. This thing was a fucking mess, and Marcia found a movie in it (particularly the trench run, which is ICONIC, maybe one of the most iconic sequences ever in film). Marcia Lucas Saved Star Wars.
Han Solo shot first. You know, I'm a purist. I often say that the only real Star Wars was the one they showed in theaters in 1977, but then that cut actually got released, and it's not quite there, either, so there's some imaginary, has-never-existed version of Star Wars that is some amalgamation of what was show in theaters in the seventies, and the changed versions that Lucas made (but which eschewed the changes I hate, like potting digital rocks in front of R2D2 in that one scene, or goofy cartoon dinosaurs walking around a PS2-era-looking Mos Eisley).
It really makes you think about what a 'film,' actually is. I think I love the story, and the filmic efforts to tell that story (which they've been doing for nearly 50 years with this one, single story) never quite get there, but I've got a version of Star Wars in my mind, and it's, like, nearly the perfect film.
We'll never see it, but I know it's out there, and that's good enough.
The version of Star Wars that is available to be watched, though, is still a 10.0/10.0 all-time-great film.
IT'S NOT CALLED A NEW HOPE. THIS MOVIE'S TITLE IS STAR WARS (1977)