Probably Casey Affleck's best performance?

Review of Gone Baby Gone (2007) by kcookandcatsco: 👍 8.0/10

It's not this movie's fault, at all, but I keep Mandela-conflating Gone Baby Gone with Gone Girl, a much-worse, much-more-insufferable film, and I keep accidentally tarring this film with that brush.

Gone Baby Gone is not Gone Girl.

Amusingly, as I was entering the title into the ReelRank database just now, the editor side of me poked at me. "Hey, shouldn't that be Gone, Baby, Gone?" And I was going to tweet something snarky, but then I thought, well, it was a novel first, so that's really the author's fault, if anything...

Nah! The novel had the commas. The filmmakers just decided to take them out, probably in way very similar to how The Facebook became Facebook, though in this case it makes the title indecipherable nonsense and arguably hurts the final product.

That said, the final product is quite good. It handles challenging subject matter maturely and compellingly. It's tense, watchable. It's just fucking good. It's a great adaptation (I presume; I've never read the novel). You can't go wrong with Gone Baby Gone, though they need to put some freaking commas in that title. Maybe on the next 20-year re-release or whatever, we can get that addressed.