A brownfaced bore
Review of In Old Arizona (1928) by alejandro_martinez: π
In Old Arizona was one of the very first all-talking pictures, and the first talkie in the western genre. Considering that this was Fox Movietone's first go at a sound feature, the quality of the recorded dialogue is to be commended, particularly in sequences shot outdoors, where it was especially difficult to use the sound equipment. The fact that it's hard to tell whether the sound was captured on-set or added in post is an impressive feat in and of itself.
In addition, the film also has the occasional nicely framed desert vistas that you can gawk at for a minute at a time.
And that's where most of the praise ends. This was bad.
The film follows the "Cisco Kid," a popular Mexican outlaw character, created by a white author, of course: O. Henry. Who better to portray a cast of Mexican characters than a troupe of white actors in brownface, struggling to hide their transatlantic accents?
Warner Baxter (later of the Crime Doctor series) plays the Cisco Kid, and his performance earned him the Academy Award for Best Actor, which is ludicrous, as he is terrible here! That's how you know there were shenanigans going on in the voting process. You'd have to be under the influence of something to view Baxter's ridiculous caricature as anything approaching good, let alone "best!" Not to mention, he's hardly a "Kid."
Dorothy Burgess, as the Cisco Kid's love interest Tonia, fares even worse than Baxter.
The acting is laughable at first, until the novelty of it wears off, and the film becomes a slog. It's a boring plot, staged and filmed in a flat, static manner, like you're sat watching crummy community theater. Unfortunately, this is how many of these early, early talkies were.
In Old Arizona was co-directed by Irving Cummings and Raoul Walsh, with the latter originally slated to play the lead until an accident occurred on set, where he lost his right eye after a jackrabbit leapt through his windshield. That's some trivia!
I almost want to cut the film some slack for being one of the first to do it, but then I could point to an earlier all-talking picture, The Singing Fool starring Al Jolson, released by Warner Bros. a few months earlier, as a superior example that is at least halfway compelling.
It did not take long into this marathon for me to find a Best Picture nominee worse than The Broadway Melody (1929). At least this one didn't win, but it's still pretty wild to think that a film this lackluster could be even considered for awards. Jolson was right: They hadn't heard nothin' yet!