When Murnau came to Hollywood
Review of Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans (1927) by alejandro_martinez: 👍
This is what happens when a Hollywood producer - William Fox - gives a German Expressionist filmmaker - F.W. Murnau - near-total creative reign over a major motion picture.
The first act of Sunrise is definitely the strongest. It's that clash of foreboding horror and surreal beauty that I strongly vibe with. You can see a clear intent behind each shot, from the off-kilter set design, to the fluid tracking shots, to the actor's facial expressions.
This was one of the first films to be released with a synchronized soundtrack, and the music is used to great effect. I especially love the horns with their droning two-note motif, like a slower version of the Jaws theme.
The visuals in the film will bring to mind many of the Universal monster films that came afterwards, particularly with all the fog, and the way George O'Brien staggers around hunched over like Frankenstein's creature.
In my opinion, the film never reaches quite the same height of the first act, as it starts to feel like it's running through the motions after a while. However, it does keep you invested with its inventive camerawork, and it does compel you to see how it all plays out.
Sunrise does make you wonder what could have been. Had there not been such a rapid push towards talking pictures; had Murnau lived past the age of 42, how differently would cinema have evolved? Would we have seen more atmospheric fables like this, told with so few words? As history stands, Sunrise distinguishes itself from the rest of its Hollywood contemporaries.