A Tale of Two Spider-Men

Review of Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026) by miss_machete: šŸ‘ 6.8/10

It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.

Brand New Day delivers on bringing Tom Holland's Spider-Man back down to Earth after being in space, not existing for five years, and using magic to alter the multiverse. This is where the character works best, getting absolutely physically and mentally pummeled by life. It makes a Marvel character human amongst a cast of gods, super soldiers, and angry green men.

But a dark shadow lingers over this film, and that is one cast by Sam Raimi. With visual allusions to the 2002 Spider-Man film, and what feels like another progin story, we've come back to the beginning. Again.

Peter is having his powers go haywire like a mid-twenties puberty, reminiscent of getting them in the first place (even referencing Toby Maguire's portrayal - they met, remember the last movie? I barely do.)

So what is new? Well, we are fully in wide canon crossover mode. No spoilers, but there was a pivotal character that was an actually pleasant surprise. And Jon Bernthal as The Punisher actually has a fun chemistry with Tom Holland. Zendaya brings a lot of strength in her performance, and Tom Holland is a master act at being so human, and the perpetual lovable underdog. But the story feels familiar - a hero who crossed the threshold to find neither him nor his home is there anymore? That's so basic, it is literally the Monomyth. Nothing asks you to engage with any depth.

There are much stronger contenders for Tom Holland's best, like his first in Spider-Man: Homecoming.

But in the end, Brand New Day is funny, pleasant, visually striking. The perfect movie for theaters... but I don't see it sticking with audiences long after they leave.