Change is Good, But Maybe Don't Change Too Much

Review of Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026) by nezzkobdamned: 👍 7.4/10

Finally, Tom Holland's Peter Parker/Spider-Man gets an actual solo outing for five minutes, and it's a film basically designed to tell him, 'Nah, don't be a loner, dude, that shit's bad for your health.'

Which is a nice message in the grand scheme of things. It's an inverse of Spider-Man 2's Spider-Man No More retelling, where we get to see a Peter Parker with no people in his life to worry about, so it's 100% workaholic Spidey.

Film gets a bit confused about its other message of accepting change, mainly because it clashes with that ongoing desire to return to the status quo; narratively, thematically, and MCU-formularity (It's late; words escape me).

The circling around of Peter's relationships with Ned and MJ are some of the nicest, most interesting moments of the film; likewise, the abrasive, reluctant kinship with John Bernthal's Frank Castle.

On that, I wasn't sure Bernthal's Punisher would work in a Spider-Man film, but they tweaked things just enough to make him blend in and still feel like an outlier. It's a sort of additional healing journey after One Last Kill.

A change in director helps this feel like the start of a new chapter. Destin Daniel Cretton is a far more stylish director than Jon Watts, and the result is a more visually interesting Spider-Man film. You can tell he wasn't too fussed about the bigger set pieces that didn't require something tangible. Not really his fault; that stuff seems like the Brussels sprouts of a Marvel movie at this point.

The problem is, it stops being a Spider-Man film for a while and bloats the runtime in the process. I like where they're going with what they do have here, but couldn't it have been in another movie?

They also drop an Iron Man 3-level twist for an ongoing plot point, so brace yourself for that. It's not bad, but they build up to fake you out, and it's about the only time the film actually surprised me.

Because yeah, far too often I felt like I was two steps ahead of where the story was going, often 30 minutes or more ahead in fact. Not a terrible problem, but when the film drops its big reveal about a character, it's already the most obvious thing in the world. Think they've lost the juice of building reveals in MCU films.

Last note. Michael Giacchino's score is sublime, the best live-action Spidey score since Elfman's for Spider-Man 2. Sitting through the end credits with that building theme? Oof, it was worth it more than the post-credits scene I was waiting for.