Fascinating, Flawed Cinematic Paranoia

Review of Under the Silver Lake (2018) by nezzkobdamned: 👍 8.1/10

It took me a long time to finally watch David Robert Mitchell's follow-up to It Follows. I was only just getting back into regularly watching films for myself back then, and that loud negative reaction likely put me off at the time.

And yet in the years since, it's lingered in the back of my mind. The more I heard about it as it got reappraised and vocal supporters of it got louder, the more intriguing a prospect it became. But you know how big watchlists get, right?

So, it turns out it's my kind of film (shocker).

More than It Follows, Under the Silver Lake blends styles, genres, eras, and conventions. The score does some heavy lifting in dragging the film between eras and genres, and in truth, Mitchell's swimmy twist on Neo Noir needs some grounding.

Andrew Garfield's Sam is a consistently intriguing protagonist. Not so much antihero as avatar for insecure projection. Sam thrusts himself into the role of protagonist to solve a conspiracy that is ultimately, intentionally, unfulfilling.

Mitchell takes a big swing here, and it's one of those I can completely understand the criticisms of even if I don't agree on many of them. These are the movies that rankle and rile up based on interpretation. I don't think it's a flawless film or anything, but it's so much more fascinating for its flaws.