Superman Returns in spirit but not in reality
Review of Superman Returns (2006) by tectash: π 5.1/10
It had been almost 19 years since we had gotten a Superman movie when this came out. This came out in 2006, which if you remember correctly prior to this we had gotten Spider-Man 2 in 2004, Batman Begins in 2005 and others but those were really shining through to make superhero movies show off their potential. The mistake this movie made was being a sequel when it should have been a reboot.
I feel bad for the actors because they were given a thankless task. The task is thankless because you can tell they were doing their best to emulate their previous counter part. The problem with this is even at it's highest potential you walk away going oh that's a nice imitation of their previous counterpart. As we all know an imitation is never as good as the real thing even at it's peak. It also makes you compare constantly rather than view them as their own separate entity.
The Donner movies were full of lighthearted hope and inspiration. This movie worst of all is dull. It's the kind of movie that's hard to narrow down because it isn't awful but it isn't good either. It's frustratingly mediocre. Now is there any positives? Yes albeit far and few between.
I did appreciate the look of metropolis it tried to emulate. Metropolis going for an art deco appearance is appreciated and there is one line I did think felt very Superman esque. When he is in the sky and says i hear everything! I feel like this was potent because it sums up how overwhelming it is to be Superman. He has the weight of so much on his shoulders.
The one idea that was new they did have felt underdeveloped. First of all I like the idea of the son becoming the father and the father becoming the son. Thing is you never gave me a connection to care about nor an interesting dynamic to place this character in. Superboy sounds good in theory but it is nothing other than mindless fluff in an already bland film.
So to sum it up it just ends up being a mixed bag. The reason this failed was because who would pick this when you had stuff like Batman Begins and Spiderman 2 to choose from? Movies breaking down barriers where as this is stuck in neutral.