It's a bird it's falling off the rails
Review of Superman III (1983) by tectash: 👎 5.5/10
After the excellent Donner films you unfortunately lose the creative force of him here. Donner was the heart and soul of what made the first two films breathe. I always state that when the artist lays the foundation down, the Hollywood accountants step in. This movie feels much more commercialized than the previous entries. Right from the opening something feels off. It goes for full blown slapstick silliness.
The previous two always were lighthearted but it balanced the comedic tone and had great moments of drama and inspirational scenes. This one fully leans into the gags. Now there are a few things that are somewhat fun in this movie. The evil Superman aspect while not nearly done to it's full potential, was a new aspect and in my book was the best part of a misguided film. Reeve always is giving it his all and seeing this aspect of him is no exception.
When people thought of a Superman movie before Superman this is probably more in line of what they thought it would be. The effects work somehow isn't as crisp as the previous entries. Richard Pryor an amazing comedian is wasted here and feels forced. That is a huge sin itself considering he was a comedic genius.
The villain in his is probably one of the most forgettable villains in any Superman movie. It feels like a poor man's Lex Luthor minus any of the charm or charisma.
It's not the worst ever but boy is it a big step down from the previous two. If morbid curiosity gets the better of you, it won't kill you but you will leave feeling like there were a few things you enjoyed but didn't like the whole dish. The beginning of the end for Superman.