An Important Landmark That Fails to Find Its Footing
Review of The Meteor Man (1993) by meet_your_double_fea: 👎 3.0/10
Robert Townsend's "The Meteor Man" marks the first time a black superhero received their own wide-release film, making it an important landmark in the history of the genre. It also sports an impressive cast of actors (James Earl Jones, Don Cheadle) and musicians (Cypress Hill, Naughty by Nature, Biz Markie). Bill Cosby's there too, but we'll try to ignore that.
However, as a film, this cult classic comedy leaves a lot to be desired. Townsend stars as Jefferson Reed, a mild-mannered schoolteacher desperate to avoid attention in his crime-ridden neighborhood. When a magical meteor crash lands on top of Reed, he finds himself gifted with the strength to stand up to the local gangs, setting him on a familiar path toward superheroism.
What drags "The Meteor Man" down is a sluggish pace and an inconsistent comedic tone. For every bit of cartoonish slapstick comedy (such as toddler criminals robbing people on the street), there's another of earnest social commentary (such as Reed condemning his neighbors for ridiculing authorities like the police while doing nothing to help the community themselves). This contrast isn't inherently bad, but the film needed to lean harder into satire for it to work. Instead, we get an absurdist comedy with not enough jokes and a sincere character drama with not enough gravity.
For more of our thoughts on "The Meteor Man," check out S2E1 of Meet Your Double Feature: "Firsts and Worsts in Superhero Cinema." Available wherever you get your podcasts.